jimukr104
True Player
    
Posts: 2,311
Joined: Jul 2012
Reputation: 32
|
RE: Eastern Ukraine Seccession
(04-14-2014 01:46 PM)Maciano Wrote: "It's as valid as everything else in Ukraine nowadays. Why is all of the sudden current Ukrainian government cute little snowflake, and west just curious observers ? They acted. Now comes reaction. Whoever expected no reaction is naive or dishonest."
What's dishonest is first arguing Putin wasn't hot for E-Ukraine from the get-go & Crimea was a historical wrong set right, and now arguing Ukraine & West provoked Russian aggression so now must bleed for their sins. Russia has a history of treating its neighbours like shit, ranging from treating them like satellite states to all-out mass murder for some kooky cause their leaders were hot for at the time. Ukraine, Baltics, Poland, etc. don't fear their hegemonic neighbour for nothing. That's why NATO's expanding: these countries WANT to be in NATO, because it sucks so much to be in Russia's sphere of influence.
I commend the Russians for straightening themselves out after communism and feel bad the way their country got plundered in the 90s, but what's happening now is not justifiable. The Russians should take some lessons in humility from the Germans, they've shown sincere regret in word and deed, real change towards their neighbours after '45. The Russians never showed any humility for those they wronged or aggressed against. They impoverished half of the European continent for their moronic mix of imperialism, Stalinism and similar shit that never did anyone any good. There's a reason why a country like Poland is way behind Belgium.
Yeah, our media is a laughable puppet show who focus on Putin's harsh line re gays, Greenpeace et al, but that's missing the other show that's playing: real Russian aggression. And it must be stopped harshly.
What aggression? They were already in Crimea and it was theirs to begin with.Again US would do the same if our border countries were going to join a military block against us.Crimean wanted to leave Ukraine.
In Eastern Ukraine the most they are doing is supporting and funding the protesters. That is the same as west is doing when they support pro EU protesters.
As for asking Russians to apologize..for what? Stalin was Georgian btw. The Russians moved into Warsaw pact countries to form a buffer but those countries historically weren't peaceful to Russia.
Poland and Lithuania had attacked Russia multiple times in history. Hungary and Romania (Italians too)were part of the Nazi war machine that launched offensive into Ukraine and Russia.
It is a known fact that the West has attacked Russia multiple times and that Russia counterattacked.
As for being in NATO... very small % of Ukrainians or even Georgians wanted to be in NATO. It is only the western supporting puppet gov't that wanted that.Same with most FSU countries. Warsaw and Baltic counties of course it is different.
Most powers treat smaller countries around them as satellites though out history..nothing new there. US had Monroe doctrine and manifest destiny.
Quote:here's an article:
I grew up in the Soviet Union, where educated people knew that propaganda is full of lies. However, if anyone told me that ?Western? (i.e., US and European) media would shamelessly spread blatant lies that they do today regarding the Ukrainian crisis, I would not believe it. Now I know better.
Ukraine was and is extremely heterogenous. It consisted of five distinct areas. One is the East and South, where most of industry is, which never spoke Ukrainian and never will. I was born in the West, in Lvov, and my parents moved to the East (Lugansk, close to my mother's birthplace) when I was about six. The Ukrainian teacher in school loved me because I was the only kid in class who could speak proper Ukrainian. Western Ukraine speaks several dialects of Ukrainian. Historically, they fought in WWI and WWII on the side of Germany, against Russia. Hence their loyalties. There is central Ukraine, which speaks what is considered literary Ukrainian and is in between in every way. There is also the part to the West of Carpatian Mountains, where people have their own dialect, which is closer to Russian than Ukrainian, and where many speak Hungarian and Romanian. They hate Western Ukrainians as much as Easterners do, due to their history in WWII. There was Crimea, which was not Ukraine at all, where ~80% of people speak Russian and 12-15% are Tatars.
Throughout its brief and inglorious history since 1991 Ukraine had two main problems: the governments were corrupt and very stupid. They pushed things that divided people, rather than those that unite them, as a reasonable government should in such a heterogenous country. Yanukovych and his gang were thieves, but West's darling Timoshenko is one of the greatest thieves in Ukrainian history. Now they appointed lesser thieves, oligarchs, as governors of Eastern regions "to normalize the situation". If they consider rampant thievery normal, what was their problem with Yanukovych? At least he was elected, whereas they are totally illegitimate by any Ukrainian constitution. What?s more, there was never quorum in Rada after February 21st, so all its decisions are equally illegitimate according to Ukrainian law. Why this does not seem to bother Western ?defenders? of law?
Precarious balance in Ukraine was upset by heavy foreign interference, in the form of paying for ?protesters? who spend months on the Maidan ostensibly without any income, and by direct visits of US and EU officials to the Maidan: Nuland from the US State Department, US senator McCain, and German Chancellor Merkel. Symmetrical moves from Russia would be visits by Putin, Medvedev, Lavrov, or members of Russian Duma to the barricades in Kharkov, Donetsk, or Lugansk, but none of them is dumb enough or shameless enough to do that. Only someone clinically stupid, totally ignorant of Ukrainian reality, or both, could have interfered the way the US and EU did in Ukraine. No wonder the result is a total disaster: Ukraine is disintegrating, going the way of Somalia and Libia, where senseless interference by Western ?democrats? also destroyed precarious balance without creating anything viable to replace it. US/EU interference had a negative impact on the whole post-Soviet region. All local dictators now get free PR without any need to lie: just showing what Kiev looks like now, or pointing out what miserable nonentities US/EU installed as Ukrainian ?leaders?, or describing the crimes their fathers and grandfathers committed while eagerly serving Hitler in WWII.
Current "government" in Kiev came to power thanks to armed support of the Right Sector. Those guys aren't even neo-Nazis, they are old-fashioned traditional Nazis. They openly worship as heroes Hitler's allies and those who served in the Waffen SS division Galichina, which Hitler used to punish civilian populations on occupied territories. Those "heroes" conducted ethnic cleansing of Poles in Western Ukraine, murdered thousands of Poles, Slovaks, and Ukrainians, some on Hitler's orders, some on their own initiative. As soon as they came to power, they showed their true colors by repealing the law on regional languages, which actually triggered the explosion against them in Crimea and South-East.
I am sure that without federalization Ukraine is dead in the water. I am beginning to think that US and EU puppet masters and their puppets in Kiev have already passed the point of no return, and that now even federalization cannot save Ukraine as a single state. Putin is patient, as the time works in his favor, but if Western Ukrainian Nazis start mass murders (which they were best known for when they served Hitler), he will have no choice but to interfere. The best advice I can give to the US and EU is this: do not let your puppets provoke Putin, or better yet, replace those nonentities with people who command respect of at least some Ukrainians.'
(This post was last modified: 04-14-2014 02:20 PM by jimukr104.)
|
|