Baldrich
Banned
Posts: 294
Joined: Sep 2015
|
RE: Madrid 2016 Data Sheet
(08-26-2016 03:59 AM)Gótico Wrote: I haven’t been to Madrid in almost a year! I live abroad; whenever I go back to Spain (via Iparralde, habitually), I tend to stay within the confines of the Basque Country. As such, I can’t comment on venues, although I have heard that the Toni 2 is in very bad state, so I would suggest visiting — if old, Transition-era melancholic bars (similarly full of old people) are your cup of tea, that is — just in case it shuts down permanently, although you won’t find any skirt to pursue. I may very well be a cursi Basque who is overly fond of public parks and gardens, but I quite like the Rosaleda of the parque del Oeste, too.
(08-19-2016 09:47 AM)... Wrote: One thing I’ve learned while being here is that being “Spanish” is not really a thing, apart from around Madrid as you mentioned. Most people identify themselves as primarily being Galician, Catalan, Andalucian etc, and people are quite different depending on what part Spain they are from.
This is because one operates under the assumption that the other one in a conversation is a compatriot. Thus, amongst Spaniards, it would be nonsensical to describe oneself as “Spanish”. The same applies to the United Kingdom, the United States or Italy; within a group of Britons, a Welshman wouldn’t respond “British” to any enquiries as to his origin, for it is assumed. Would a Californian, brought to Vermont by circumstance (employment, perhaps), describe himself as an American or a Californian before a group of Vermonters? Spain undoubtedly has regional variety and flavour, which other countries lack or, perhaps more crudely in the case of France, formerly possessed but supressed. If you notice, Spanish nationals abroad do introduce themselves, when asked, as Spaniards; only TV3-watching, Ara-reading, Esquerra-voting separatists hide their passports.
Spain was actually one of the first states in Western Europe to develop a national consciousness; the prompt unification and, much later, the resistance against the French in the War of Independence (known in English as the Peninsular War) and the Carlist conflicts are all evidence of this. Even before the Islamic conquest of much of the Iberian Peninsula, a Spanish identity can be said to have emerged; Saint Isidore, writing in the 7th century, already makes an invocation to Mater Hispania (Mother Spain) in his Historia de regibus Gothorum, Vandalorum et Suevorum.
(08-18-2016 11:41 AM)Baldrich Wrote: Oh about the Spanishness -- I’ve actually gotten OTHER Spanish people to tell me this about Madrid. The problem is that in Madrid Spanishness is given a rather narrow definition which shuts out anybody who doesn’t conform to it. Thus, Andalusians are mocked for their accent, Catalans are derided, etc. Madrid is very centralist, stuffy and closed-minded in many ways on a personal level. In fact you will find much of the rest of Spain hates Madrid.
I will never accept fascism/francoism or Communism. I value freedom, as I said earlier. Freedom, economic as well as personal, rule of law, separation of Church & State, none of this fascist crap some people seem to like.
As for the women in Franco’s Spain...sorry I don’t think that’s a model to follow. Feminism is not good, but neither is traditionalist Catholicism or Islam.
I will agree on Madrid’s centralism, but I think Andalusians and Catalans are mocked everywhere. Similarly, everyone thinks the Basques are autistic faggots who will never touch a woman in their lives and direct more words at their long-dead ancestors and cows than they do at their own mothers; we think so, too, but at least we have Welthauptstadt Bilbao, the greatest metropolis to have existed. Spain, left- or right-leaning, is “stuffy” and “close-minded” in its entirety. Las dos Españas, Antonio and Manuel Machado, Francisco (yes, the caudillo) and Ramón Franco, Unamuno, Maragall, etc. This really is a topic for Spanish history and politics; should you open one, I would try to contribute.
José Antonio was a fascist, Baldrich; Franco was an opportunist, authoritarian army general, who sided with the Americans after the Second World War came to a close and produced the Spanish Miracle. That the Church came to his arms is hardly surprising when the republicans mutilated, castrated and executed priests (the Bishop of Barcelona included), raped nuns and persecuted the faithful. I agree on the importance of freedom, but sometimes one must choose between two dictatorships: in face of the Second Republic, death would be preferable. Laïcité, when arranged à la française, can only bring the destruction of the national patrimony; we need not become ultramontanists overnight, but there is no ill in recognising Spain as a Catholic country and attaching some legal importance to the Catholic Church as the state religion. Pío Moa is in order, my friend.
¿Qué propone usted? Having dismissed things present and things past alike, what system do you propose for our women? This I ask as an increasingly fervid conservative.
Most of the "old" bars in Madrid are shutting down. No one under the age of 50 wants to be caught dead in any of those rancid bars. Barcelona, which is way more European, modern, vanguard and progressive compared to fascistic Madrid, has no such bars (that's what gives Barcelona the "coolness" factor that Madrid will never ever ever have, no matter how hard they try). Barcelona was always the most open and modern Spain had to offer. That's normal though -- because they're not really "Spanish" in culture and don't feel that way. They will be independent soon, I guarantee you that.
Looking at how you express yourself, I can definitely tell you are Basque -- no offense meant but sometimes you guys are too "brutos!" when talking! I have had a lot of clashes with some Basques, although nothing in a bad sense. I'm sure you will understand me when I say I am much more in tune with the "Mediterranean" attitude of "I don't give a F" which doesn't happen up north.
Your comments about nationality or Spanishness make no sense. You totally misunderstood the point. "Being Spanish is not really a thing" in that MOST people outside Madrid and the Castilla regions DO NOT like to be called Spanish and many will NOT identify with what MADRID says "Spanishness" is. Spain, thankfully, isn't all about sangrias and bullfighting. That's the bad Spain, the central Spain, the Spain of old, of Franco, of poverty, ignorance and Catholicism (being redundant, I know).
Why do you operate on assumptions? I like to operate on facts, not assumptions and the fact of the matter is that many people outside Madrid and Castilla do NOT like to be called "españoles" without any context on what that means.
With regard to how Americans identify themselves...most Americans identify first by race/ethnicity. Very few people use the term "American" without a hyphen. Most people say "Italian-American" or "Hispanic-American", or "Muslim-American", there are endless labels, which is why many Americans are a bit surprised when in Europe, most "Europeans" (yes, in quotations) lump everyone as "American" as if we were all exactly with the same characteristics. We are an extremely diverse country.
Also, to assume anyone who doesn't identify as a Spaniard is an "esquerra TV3" follower is why I have so many problems with many Spanish people who think like you. Why can't you just respect the FACT that MANY people, leftist or not, do NOT like to be called Spanish? CIU in Catalonia is from from being a left-wing party and their voters are CATALAN pro-independence from Spain. But they are quite conservative. Likewise in your own region, the PNV is far from being left-wing....so just think for a while about how you label people.
Spain's national consciousness was imposed and it has had THREE CIVIL WARS because of that very question which is still NOT settled.
And I'm sorry but if you follow pseudo-historians like Pio Moa, I have nothing else to discuss with you. I like serious scholarship, not the BS churned out by Pio Moa and propagandists like fatso Cesar Vidal.
Franco: I agree he was an opportunist...but if you really believe that is a model for Spain to follow again, there is nothing we can discuss properly. I was raised to defend freedom, limited government, protestant-style liberties...not this Catholic fascist or authoritarian bullcrap. One of the reasons why Spanish women are so repressed about sex is precisely due to that Catholic background which is thankfully, FINALLY, disappearing. I love the video when Carrero Blanco dies. As you say in Madrid "de Madrid al cielo" and never as relevant!
I AGREE with you that BOTH leftists and rightists in Spain are stuffy and closed-minded. This country is sometimes very stifling, there is no debate whatsoever between sides...but please use serious sources when making your point, not jokes like Pio Moa.
Yeah, the "reds" raped nuns...and the Catholic Church abducted children and MURDERED many, many people. As an institution, no other has done more damage to freedom and prosperity like the Roman Catholic Church.
¿Qué propone usted"? you ask me. Well, I'd like Spanish women to be more feminine but LIBERATED at the same time. In short, more North, less "Spanish" and Catholic. I talk to girls from all over the world and the attitude here of women is one of the worst I've seen in my life. Why anyone would want to come for the women here is beyond me.
And by the way guys, cut the crap about how Franco was "great". If anything, Franco made this country even MORE BETA than it was. There is actually a great book written by a right-leaning author who says that Franco actually made Spain the joke it is today. Franco openly mocked the Spaniards in an interview which is on youtube....he was asked "do you think it is difficult to govern the Spanish people"? His answer? "Difficult? NOOO, on the contrary!"
He was absolutely right. He also said "My compatriots are imbeciles"...so I agree, at least Franco knew his countrymen...but a model to follow? Err...no.
|
|