Great insights from the guys.
I partially agree and disagree with Noir.
I agree it's a red flag and a non-starter to verbalise a request like hers but I disagree you should act nonchalantly. Too much liberal bullshit. Especially, she's Mexican and it's a part and parcel of Mexican culture for a man to call the shots.
I think Dalaran1991 has provided fantastically sagacious input as well and I'm pretty much on his side but, well, seems like I (want to?) believe not all is lost. After all, despite the fact women are alike, there's some variance in what people are like, with their upbringing, culture, belief systems and so on. Let's make na assumption a woman is allowed to put forward one major test (but
not excute it) every few years. The reason for that is explained towards the bottom of my reply to you.
(09-16-2018 06:08 PM)arafat scarf Wrote: Here to vent and possibly get some brutal feedback/criticism from the forum.
I've been seeing a Mexican girl for the last 7 months. We've agreed to exclusivity (though not b/f,g/f) and during our time together she has been incredibly attentive, nurturing and doting. She doesn't nag, and she's not materialistic. Things are good inside and outside the bedroom, and I've been very happy with this one up to now. She treats her family well, she treats me well and makes me feel like a man. I've kept my game tight with her and I haven't been needy, desperate, or weak.
But, there's a problem.
She's been traveling alone on a trip to Europe for the last few weeks, and this week she's going to stay at a male friend's apartment for 7 days in Paris. I don't know the exact nature of their past relationship, but I know he doesn't have a girlfriend now. She also mentioned previously time that this friend likes to party.
I think I can chime in because it happened to me as well (with more than one girl). Ironically, she was Mexican as well.
(09-16-2018 06:08 PM)arafat scarf Wrote: The thing is, she hasn't tried to hide anything about staying with this guy. The trip was planned many months ago and she had told me that she was intending to stay with him when we first started seeing each other. There's nothing underhanded or particularly sneaky happening below the surface.
That doesn't matter. Remember the First Commandment-
never listen to a woman, look at what she does. She may not have an intention but the damn thing about humans is that the opportunity makes a thief. Uniformly, those guys
intend to fuck the girl (if they hadn't already). There's a
clear reason why she can stay at his for a week. He may not have verbalised (in my case, the girl knew the guy fancied her for years) he has romantic interest in her but trust me - things don't happen for no reason and if she was ugly, she wouldn't have been invited).
He will have full seven days to work his magic. Humans are weak - especially under influence. She'll be ovulating, have a few drinks, a joint, and it will "just happen". She'll have an excuse, regardless if she tells you or not, that "I was drunk, I didn't plan it". Even worse, women cunning as they can be, she may engineer a pretext - you guys will have a call that will end up really sour so she'd have something to blame you on. You won't sleep peacefully that night.
Strangely, a baby that will pop out of her belly will look somewhat French (OK, that's a bit extreme scenario but not impossible and as the Heartiste saying goes, alpha fux, beta bux...) and you should manoeuvre your romantic life so as to have as little doubt as possible.
(09-16-2018 06:08 PM)arafat scarf Wrote: Yet it still doesn't feel right and last Thursday I told her that I didn't like the situation, that she was crossing a line, and that I would have expected that she was going to change plans given how things are going between us. I didn't lose my cool, but I told her sternly.
It doesn't feel right for good reasons - it doesn't feel right in your gut because a man's role for millennia was to protect and guard a female from other males, not to hand her in to them on a silver platter. If she's "yours", she shouldn't be in a position to act favourably upon requests from men who intend fucking her (she's adult, she
knows he wants to fuck her.)
The liberalised times fucked up and distorted relationships in respect with what should and shouldn't be allowed. A Saudi woman wouldn't even entertain a thought to verbalise such a decision for fear of ending in a hospital with multiple fractures. A Saudi man, if he were to learn about your tribulations that his woman is about to sleep in another's man house in Paris, would laugh in your face and if she actually dared to say it, she would not be allowed to return. End of story.
(09-16-2018 06:08 PM)arafat scarf Wrote: She insisted the guy's only a friend, that nothing will happen because that's not what she wants, that she only wants to be with me. She also mentioned that she would have already cheated already on the trip if something was going to happen, that she's had opportunities. She then offered to not stay with him and find a hostel; that as a couple we need to 'treat each other's hearts well'. But I said to go ahead and stay with him and that things will be stronger between us if she comes back and we're together again.
Yup, same story, same drivel. How many times we've all heard (I told you -
never listen to a woman) we're "the one and only man in her heart", we're "special", we're "true love", just to have her suck another guy's dick weeks or months later and you will never see or hear from her again. They are, for better or wrose, emotionally driven creatures. Read that sentence
again. Women are, above all, driven by what they
feel like. Never ever give a woman a chance to stray as long as you have someone pointing a loaded Glock 19 to your temple.
What I did with the Mexican, I kept rationally arguing (a mistake -
never try to talk a girl rationally out of something) and she would keep pushing my buttons (they all know what they do and they love it, even if denying), at some point I just had enough, and left the table without a word. I think that wasn't the best but better than coyly agreeing with her - it only would establish a precedence that I'm weak and for the pussy willing to jeopardise so much of my wellbeing, including raising someone else's kid (think again - you won't sleep well for a week thinking what is she doing with him and possible ramifications of it). After mulling things over, the girl didn't go down to England to stay with her "long-time male friend", and admitted it wasn't right. However, the damage was done and the dynamics changed between us. A woman who truly is into you (or she says so - though, remember
never listen to a woman, this rule applies at all times), wouldn't entertain an idea in the first place. It's a red flag, nonetheless, I'm afraid. Also, consider a fact which tells a lot - does she have more male or female friends (if the former, that's a bad, bad news - consider yourself warned). Throw her out the door, if she stays with him. It takes a man to do that but I'd rather do that than be a pussy. Paradoxically, in my opinion, she won't respect you for letting her do that and, inevitably, sooner or later, she will break up with you. Then again, if it's just sportfucking, you can just as well shrug your shoulders and let her do whatever she pleases to do, but I reply to you on the assumption, if interpreted correctly, that this girl matters to you a lot.
There are three actionable things you can do which, in my opinion, are worth executing:
Option A
Sometimes the best way to defend yourself is to attack. It's not a very masculine tactic but I told you - never rationally reason with a woman. Tell her that what she's planning to do hurts you. You thought she was special, but she would be acting like a god damn whore (she'll get, as Mexican girls do, livid. Oh boy, she'll get livid and vehemently deny she's a whore). Well, it's all semantics. You hope she's not, and she
wouldn't act like one. It's up to her if she wants to hurt
you or not. If she keeps insisting and goes with the flow and values her "male friend" more than you, she told you that she, in fact, doesn't give damn about you. You saved yourself time and energy investing in a wrong girl.
Option B
She's Mexican. Bring out a part of true Machismo. She understands it to a tee. She's
Mexican. Your pride and dick can't allow for that. Put your foot down, draw red line, either my way or the highway. Tell her in no uncertain terms, that if she goes and stays with him, it's over. You truly, if you go with this option, need to think what you say and act congruently. It's a tough option.
Option C
Just book a hotel for her. If you can't, tell her you did (often anyway you can cancel without incurring costs). This may smell a bit providesque but still better thing than just letting her do what she wants. Better yet, if you have time, why not, as Dalaran1991 suggests, join her in Europe for some time, if you can? Her reaction will tell you a lot. You'll know what to do by the way she reacts.
I think, I would go with an option C. If her reaction was dismissive, follow up with option B.
(09-16-2018 06:08 PM)arafat scarf Wrote: Of course, I don't really believe that. I said it because I didn't want to restrict her. And I don't... I want her to make good decisions on her own, at least as far as major matters like this are concerned.
I know how these girls are and my expectations are pretty low. Yet I'm still disappointed with the outcome of this one. I'm upset with the situation, upset with her judgment, and upset with myself for letting it come to this point. But getting upset doesn't change anything, and I feel the best thing to do is to start phasing her out. Aside from this incident, she's been great and this has been really the only thing wrong she's done.
Think of a woman like a kid, whom you need to teach, then it will become so much better - a woman (in a relationship) needs proper boundary. She needs to understand what in your book is allowed or not. As long as the boundaries are reasonable, congruent and consistently enforced, she'll feel safe. She's testing this boundaries big time (which, in a way is good - she's testing your mettle because she's quite likely into you in a serious way but still not sure) and it is up to you to make up your mind - do you want to keep it serious with her or not? Only you know the answer (however, in the ideal world, as mentioned before, she should have never ever entertained the idea, she's not stupid 14 years old and
knows the dick is on offer and you know she knows that you know.
(09-16-2018 06:08 PM)arafat scarf Wrote: She'll be tough to lose, but I just don't see a way back.
If I permit the situation, there's no way I can respect myself for letting my girl crash at another dude's house for a week. If I don't permit the situation and strongly communicate that her behavior is unacceptable, the dynamic shifts to me as the possessive one putting restrictions on her and I'm made to look like a simp. And then no matter the case, I won't be able respect her for thinking that it's alright to sleep over at another guy 'friend's' house for a week when we're together.
Live and learn.
You've got, in my opinion, nothing to lose to try out options A, B, and/or C. At least you'll learn something. Phasing things out quietly is not a true man's way. It's a girl's way to go about things passively and indirectly. I believe you should confront the issue (I think you already did but no specific resolution was met) heads on and get a clear answer: yes or no, and nothing in between.
You say that "
the dynamic shifts to me as the possessive one putting restrictions on her and I'm made to look like a simp." Precisely. I was accused of being jealous, just like you envision. I tried to spin it around and be nonchalant and that's what I did but, honestly, If I didn't care, would I put the issue on the table? No. Don't make my mistake and be fully congruent. OWN your (reasonable) jealousy (it's a different story to call your girl every 5 minutes every time she goes to get groceries in fear she fucks a cashier and a different to agree with her to stay many nights over at another man's house abroad). Just be proud of it, and if she accuses you, look straight in her eyes, and say calmly that, yes, you're jealous and won't entertain her capricious demands and if she really wants to hurt you, it's up to her but it's over. Be calm, don't raise your voice, don't play into her game, accept the worst resolution - if you're mentally fine with it, you come out stronger, whatever she chooses. I think your intuition is correct and your guts know what to do but all this liberal western feminism occluded your mind.
After the confrontation you'll have soap opera drama and probably a big emotional fit of hers, exploding like fierce fireworks on a New Year's eve. Don't get manipulated and sit it out. I repeat,
sit it out. Don't message her, don't call her, don't seek her out. It'll be a turning point. If she persists and decides to stay at his, she's never been your girl and you're saving yourself major headaches down the road. It's hard, but the only way is to end it. However, if she comes to you, agrees with you it was a bad idea and stays on her own then, my friend, she really cares about you and you're in the drivers seat and experience the best sex of your life thereafter...
Until a new big test a few years later comes along like a freewheeling cart full of safety pin released grenades and, as they usually do, in the least expected moment and when you'll be on the down low.* But this time, you'll be ready.
* I sound cynical but the nature, drilled down, over millennia of evolution, into females' primitive brain stem structures that it is necessary to ceaselessly test a males survival and reproductive potential. It's a rare find, a true gem of a female that would help out the browbeaten man but don't expect it until you teach a woman good behaviours.