DirectDanger
Wingman
  
Posts: 826
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 70
|
|
| 12-02-2012 05:30 PM |
|
|
Basil Ransom
International Playboy
     
Posts: 4,877
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 112
|
RE: Fat Inflation
I also wonder if the ideal weight is going up because plenty of men are pussies who want to placate (fat) women and make them feel good about themselves.
Interesting point, but a quibble:
(12-02-2012 05:09 PM)Samseau Wrote: It's not that more women are obese than men, it's that fatness hurts a woman's SMV moreso than it hurts a man's SMV.
Actually, this is wrong.
An earlier post of mine:
(07-26-2011 01:01 AM)basilransom Wrote: I crunched the data a few days ago, and American women are more than twice as fat as American men. I define fatness as number of inches in waist circumference away from ideal, ideal being 32" for men, 24" for women. By ideal, I mean an obtainable ideal for the typical man and woman. The age group is 20-29. Link
Edit: These calculations were with the median, not the mean.
Men: 90.9 cm = 35.8 inches waist circumference
Women: 84.3 cm = 33.2 inches waist circumference
Men: 35.8-32 = 3.8
Women: 33.2-24=9.2
9.2/3.8= 2.42, or 142% fatter. If you say 25" is ideal for women, on average, it's 8.2/3.8 = 2.16, or 116% fatter.
BMI understates the fatness of women. Plenty a man can be 23, 25, 27 BMI and still look good, and perhaps not even be remotely fat. For a girl that does not weight train or seriously play sports, weight north of 22 BMI is fat, pure and simple. And even waist circumference probably understates female corpulence. Men store fat more around their bellies, and women around their thighs and arms.
Also the obesity cutoff for women is too high - it should be lower:
(04-05-2012 10:08 AM)basilransom Wrote: As for obesity, doctors are starting to come around to what I've been saying, that there are far more fat women than men, and that the BMI threshold of 30 for 'obese' status for women is way too high. Here a doctor says that the threshold for obesity for women should be lowered to 24 and for men to 28. As I've said elsewhere, there are twice as many fat women as men, and changing the BMI threshold for obesity as the doctor recommends would swiftly reflect that, instead of the bullshit the CDC et al currently publish, saying that there are roughly equal numbers of male and female fatties.
BMI is a rough proxy for body fat percentages. Men and women, past a certain body fat %, are deemed obese or overweight. The exact percentage differs among health authorities, and the men's cutoff is about five percentage points lower than the women's. But whatever the cutoff, BMI understates the rate of obesity, especially among women. If you declare that men and women with body fat percentages above say, 25% and 30% respectively are obese, you'll find many more women than men who are obese, as the linked article makes clear.
(This post was last modified: 12-02-2012 05:34 PM by Basil Ransom.)
|
|
| 12-02-2012 05:33 PM |
|
The following 3 users Like Basil Ransom's post:3 users Like Basil Ransom's post
Samseau, storm, RandalGraves
|
storm
Alpha Male
   
Posts: 1,307
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 21
|
RE: Fat Inflation
(This post was last modified: 12-02-2012 10:00 PM by storm.)
|
|
| 12-02-2012 10:00 PM |
|
The following 1 user Likes storm's post:1 user Likes storm's post
Samseau
|