Post: #1

Anyone had a girl ask them this before? I've had this a couple of times post-coitally something along these lines:

'You could have so many other girls, why me?'

Truth is often, 'you seemed easy', but I've usually followed it up with a compliment and maybe a joke.

I don't know if it's genuine or a shit test, I suppose it could be either depending on the girl.

Post: #2

We need to stop with the whole "shit test" thing.

I swear if I ever find out who made up that lame, weesh phrase, I am hitting them over the head with a full Mickeys 40oz.

Back to your question.

She is just fishing for compliments.

Girls do that all the time.

Post: #3

Makes sense G, it was just a line that was coming up, so I thought there might be more to it.

Post: #4

(06-30-2012 02:49 PM)thegmanifesto Wrote:  We need to stop with the whole "shit test" thing.

I swear if I ever find out who made up that lame, weesh phrase, I am hitting them over the head with a full Mickeys 40oz.

Back to your question.

She is just fishing for compliments.

Girls do that all the time.

I've seen someone do that at a party years ago

YEah, I don't even know what the hell "shit test" is. I guess another PUA term.

Post: #5

Yes many girls have asked me this. I just say something like "well because I like you, we get along, don't we?"

Post: #6

Answer a question with a question, "why not you"?

Post: #7

I love this question. I put my hand on my heart, look her in the eyes and give her some chick lit crap, laughing my ass inside if is she actually falling for that romanctic mumbo jumbo.

Best way to make sure you see the girl again.

Just start your sentence with : Hmm, baby it's just because i get a certain [insert romantic frase here] when i'm around you. The way you [insert chick crap here] when you look at me makes me [ blahblahblah] inside. I don't know how to explain it, it's just a raw vibe i'm getting from you and i don't sense in other girls.

Top it of with : it's like you put a spell on me and i drawn towards you like an invisible magnet...

At this point you can stop talking because she too busy taking her clothes of.

Post: #8

"I wanted to see if you're just like everyone else I have met in my life... We'll see" wink
- stolen from MikeCF

"I thought you were cute, assumed you would be a fun and live in the moment type of girl"

"Uh oh(sarcastic joking tone) someone may be fishing!" (smile)

"I thought you were attractive so I said hello."

"You looked like you were having an awful night so I decided to fix the problem. (smile)"
I abuse this one and go to dance floor

Hard to tell which one to go with but it's all gold, all above have worked for me

Post: #9

it is genuine. you didn't make her "special". corny or not, every person wants to be somehow special and liked/appreciated for their own unique trait. you didn't assure her why you like her beside her looks

if you get this a lot take it as sign that you spend waaaaaaaay too much time in "attraction land". try to connect more. even the little things like 'we both liked climbing trees in our childhood' is some form of connection and will take further than DHVing or whatever the fuck it's called

Post: #10

It the end of the day,it doesn't really matter what you say, if she asks this question that means she is DTF.

Post: #11

(06-30-2012 02:24 PM)Surreyman Wrote:  Anyone had a girl ask them this before? I've had this a couple of times post-coitally something along these lines:

'You could have so many other girls, why me?'

Truth is often, 'you seemed easy', but I've usually followed it up with a compliment and maybe a joke.

I don't know if it's genuine or a shit test, I suppose it could be either depending on the girl.

Your eyes sparkle like the savannah, your hair is like rivulets of stardust falling from the sky, I would like to take you for a picnic just so I could kiss you on the cheek.

Hey look! There's a...

Post: #12

(06-30-2012 02:49 PM)thegmanifesto Wrote:  full Mickeys 40oz.

Damn, I just had flashbacks of high school.

Post: #13

(06-30-2012 04:32 PM)Deb Auchery Wrote:  It the end of the day,it doesn't really matter what you say, if she asks this question that means she is DTF.

Exactly- this indicates that she has made the decision to bang you, and is looking to you for reassurance that she has made the right decision. She wants to feel that the two of you have made some connection, which is why I think Neil's romantic style answer is much better than cocky funny before the bang.


After the bang, you can answer "because you have a nice ass" and get away with it

Post: #14

(06-30-2012 04:42 PM)MrXY Wrote:  

(06-30-2012 04:32 PM)Deb Auchery Wrote:  It the end of the day,it doesn't really matter what you say, if she asks this question that means she is DTF.

Exactly- this indicates that she has made the decision to bang you, and is looking to you for reassurance that she has made the right decision. She wants to feel that the two of you have made some connection, which is why I think Neil's romantic style answer is much better than cocky funny before the bang.


After the bang, you can answer "because you have a nice ass" and get away with it

100% agree with this, only issue is discerning "why me" versus "why me you can have anyone here". You go to cocky funny if it's more of a hmm why did u talk to me. Versus you're so interesting/attractive I want to fuck you. In the second case yes immediately compliment/be direct.

Post: #15

My token line, delivered to at least half the girls I've banged (i've mentioned it on the boards before):

"You weren't the cutest girl down at the police station that day, but something about your crooked teeth made me wanna take you home."

Post: #16

I like to say something vague like "you seem kind of interesting"

to which 99% of girls respond "good interesting or bad interesting?"

to which I respond "I'm still trying to figure that out"

at that point she may try to punch you (jokingly), but you can usually block it and segway into a second round of coitus.

Post: #17

Generally, if a girl wants a complement after you fuck her, then give her a compliment.

If she was kind and nice to you, gave up the pussy without much effort on your part, then a compliment is the least you could do to return the favor. Don't go overboard. A simple, "You have a nice smile" will suffice.


It also helps if you want to bang her again, since she'll internalize the moment you gave her a compliment with her post-coital feelings.

Post: #18

I don't use a whole lot of canned material but this is one of those things I encounter enough that I have a standard response.

"You just had a weird, positive energy about you so I decided to figure out what you're all about."

It's better than telling them that they seemed easy.

Post: #19

It is obvious that these girls have some insecurity complex and that's the reason why they ask this question and other questions like it. Insecurity is kind of a turn off for me but this is good because you can use this to your advantage and bang her multiple times.

Give her answers that make her feel more secure, whatever will do it for her and you will definitely have fun banging her again. A small compliment would do it but dont go all in and start to sound like a wuss.

J-Mackin