(04-02-2017 10:18 PM)Isaac Jordan Wrote: (04-02-2017 06:49 PM)JayJuanGee Wrote: What am I missing? If everyone wants to talk about something else, what the fuck you doing in the bitcoin thread?
I don't think anyone disagrees with the assertion that Bitcoin is (currently) by far the most important cryptocurrency, whether you're looking at it from a historical perspective, or technological, or financial, etc.
Don't get me wrong. I am not basing any of my bitcoin thread purity assertions on any kind of claim that bitcoin is superior.
I am merely asserting that this thread was created with bitcoin as a topic, and initially the topic, as created by Pants, was "wow look at bitcoin the price has gone up a lot."
With the passage of time, this thread became the all things bitcoin thread, and largely when other guys attempted to create bitcoin related threads in the forum, they were directed to this thread.
There is not really any reason (as far as I know) that a new bitcoin related thread could not be created on RVF so long as the thread offers something different from this thread... and maybe even some kind of twist.. but we have an alt coin thread and we have a bitcoin thread, and if RVF guys are sufficiently interested in some subtopic of a thread, there could be other RVF threads that could be created. I don't know, but for some reason, contrary to what seems reasonable, RVF guys seem to be a bit less interested in bitcoin than they should be.
I mean, I consider bitcoin to be a very decent tool that can be used very well in traveling - but maybe in the end, RVF guys are not really finding this aspect of bitcoin to be as practical as might be theoretically considered to be the case.
I have a few reasons for getting into bitcoin, but one aspect of bitcoin was definitely the portability aspect to be able to potentially have access to assets while traveling and not having to declare or to potentially report at borders.
(04-02-2017 10:18 PM)Isaac Jordan Wrote: But Bitcoin has spurred the creation of an entirely new industry ("FinTech"), in which many systems (like Ethereum) will undoubtedly play an important role, and the decisions made regarding one blockchain often have consequences for other cryptos. You simply can't discuss Bitcoin any more without including in the conversation the larger context of the cryptocurrency space as whole. You miss a lot otherwise.
Hey Isaac, there is nothing wrong with that. If you are making various connections in your discussions about various other cryptos, whether that is Ethereum or any other crypto, then I doubt anyone (including me) is going to complain that you are off topic for this bitcoin thread.
I think that I have more of a problem with guys coming into this thread to pump various alts and without even attempting to make any connection with bitcoin, and that is called thread hijacking and really there is no reason those kinds of posts might not be more suitable for the alt coin thread.
Why do we need to read such clutter here if there is not even attempt to connect the topic to bitcoin, especially when bitcoin is already a pretty fucking BIG topic (as you already mentioned several times in your earlier posts)
(04-02-2017 10:18 PM)Isaac Jordan Wrote: And sure, for the purposes of this thread in particular I would think that any alt-coin discussions should in some way include the impact on Bitcoin's price/development/industry role/etc. Any conversations focusing SPECIFICALLY on an alt-coin without ANY bearing on Bitcoin should of course go in the Alternatives to Bitcoin thread (or perhaps a thread of their own).
I think that is the general idea. I mean RVF is already kind of known by its longer term members as a pretty decent forum when it comes to disallowing trolls and thread hijackers.
(04-02-2017 10:18 PM)Isaac Jordan Wrote: But saying that we shouldn't discuss other cryptos in the Bitcoin thread is like saying we shouldn't talk about Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama in the Donald Trump thread. Yeah, it's technically titled the DONALD TRUMP thread, but the other players are obviously relevant in various contexts within the political sphere. Same goes for Bitcoin and other cryptos.
I'm not really sure if you are bringing up the greatest analogy, but I think that I get your point, and I don't really think that I am saying that you cannot talk about alts, because I already conceded that there is likely 5% to 10% of posts that deviate in that direction - however, I am saying that it seems inappropriate when the thrust of your post is about other coins and there is a much better thread for that (the alt coin thread), and in that regard, what the fuck are guys posting in the bitcoin thread about alts, except for the fact that they believe that the bitcoin thread has a bigger audience. A bigger audience seems to be an insufficient reason to post about alt coins in the bitcoin thread.
It is like going to the Donald Trump thread and posting something about Hilary Clinton that has nothing to do with Donald Trump and, merely because you believe that the Donald Trump thread has a bigger audience.... The topics of Hilary Clinton may be connected with Donald Trump, but if you are merely posting about ear infection that she had in 1995, then guys might wonder why the fuck are you posting about that in the Donald Trump thread.
Isaac. I think that in the end, you and I don't really see this topic too differently, yet I can understand why you and possibly other guys may come to the conclusion that I am attempting to create and dictate rules for this bitcoin thread, when I really don't think that I am (even though I understand how reasonable RVF guys might come to that conclusion from time to time)
I mean in the end, when push comes to shove, if RVF guys are coming to the bitcoin thread and just posting here and there about alt coins, I doubt that anyone is going to say anything, even me... But if there seems to be a pattern in which they are appear to be derailing and/or cluttering the bitcoin thread with non-relevant topics, then that would likely cause me to say something, I mean if I noticed it... but most of the time, pointing out that there is a better thread for the alt coin topic should not be offensive to anyone who is really attempting to talk about thread relevant substance rather than attempting to distract and/or derail thread topics.
For example, if someone comes into the bitcoin thread and generally posts about bitcoin topics, no one is really going to say anything if he posts a couple times about other coins... but if someone comes into the thread several times, and continues to post about off topics, wouldn't that cause concern from RVF guys? Don't we want to be courteous to other RVF members regarding attempting to post our bitcoin and alt coin topics within the topic appropriate threads?