(11-05-2014 05:51 AM)Matt Forney Wrote: SJWs are completely divorced from reality. Unemployment (and underemployment) is skyrocketing, the college loan crisis is unraveling, the middle class is collapsing... all these morons care about are boutique issues. Abortion has literally been untouched since Roe v. Wade. Gay marriage has zero relevance to 98% of the population (yeah yeah yeah, I get the greater cultural context, but it's not an immediate issue that affects the average person's welfare).
(11-05-2014 06:53 AM)worldwidetraveler Wrote:(11-05-2014 02:02 AM)Cattle Rustler Wrote:(11-04-2014 07:48 PM)worldwidetraveler Wrote:(11-04-2014 07:23 PM)Brian Shima Wrote: Cattle Rustler someone earlier in the thread mention that you do oil work. Why would you vote for a Democrat and put your job on the line and not stay neutral? I mean Green Party seriously!? They would love to shut down oil rigs and leave thousands without work
I don't think CR works which is probably why he voted Democrat. hah
The more you know.....(and I do work)
First of all, I am neither a Republican nor Democrat.
With that said, let's talk about that chart, which is based on 2005 data. What exactly entails a state being a republican or a state being democrat according to your chart?
I'll give you a hint, some of those republican states would fit democrat states according to the same logic used for that chart...
![[Image: AiQSYaMl.png]](http://i.imgur.com/AiQSYaMl.png)
(11-05-2014 07:36 AM)Deluge Wrote: This is unique to America post the mid-20th century party realignment. In the rest of the Western world the wealthy area's almost always vote centre-right and by large margins even if they are socially liberal and in the big cities. Why does America buck this trend?
(11-05-2014 07:50 AM)Blick Mang Wrote:(11-05-2014 07:36 AM)Deluge Wrote: This is unique to America post the mid-20th century party realignment. In the rest of the Western world the wealthy area's almost always vote centre-right and by large margins even if they are socially liberal and in the big cities. Why does America buck this trend?
Simple answer, our cultural DNA.
Americans would rather live in danger as a wolf than live in complete safety as a sheep.
Americans would rather live freely in poverty than be wealthy as a slave.
Public discourse over the past century has been almost entirely centered on that line of thinking as well as justifying deviations from it. As an example, of course Americans want health care, and think everyone else should have health care. We just don't think it's the Federal governments responsibility to provide it, nor should we be mandated to purchase it.
When it comes to gun control, most of us would rather live in a dangerous society where we are free to defend ourselves, than live as slaves reliant on the government to protect our lives.
If you understand the cultural logic behind Americans, our entire political system will make sense.
(11-05-2014 07:57 AM)Deluge Wrote:(11-05-2014 07:50 AM)Blick Mang Wrote:(11-05-2014 07:36 AM)Deluge Wrote: This is unique to America post the mid-20th century party realignment. In the rest of the Western world the wealthy area's almost always vote centre-right and by large margins even if they are socially liberal and in the big cities. Why does America buck this trend?
Simple answer, our cultural DNA.
Americans would rather live in danger as a wolf than live in complete safety as a sheep.
Americans would rather live freely in poverty than be wealthy as a slave.
Public discourse over the past century has been almost entirely centered on that line of thinking as well as justifying deviations from it. As an example, of course Americans want health care, and think everyone else should have health care. We just don't think it's the Federal governments responsibility to provide it, nor should we be mandated to purchase it.
When it comes to gun control, most of us would rather live in a dangerous society where we are free to defend ourselves, than live as slaves reliant on the government to protect our lives.
If you understand the cultural logic behind Americans, our entire political system will make sense.
I know the libertarian mindset is why America is the most supportive of small government and culturally conservative, but I don't see how that explains why your wealthiest areas vote for a centre-left party. Everywhere else the wealthy areas will vote staunchly right-wing because of economic issues, even if they are socially liberal. Similarly working class areas will vote staunchly left-wing even if they are socially conservative.
(11-05-2014 08:10 AM)It_is_my_time Wrote:(11-05-2014 07:57 AM)Deluge Wrote:(11-05-2014 07:50 AM)Blick Mang Wrote:(11-05-2014 07:36 AM)Deluge Wrote: This is unique to America post the mid-20th century party realignment. In the rest of the Western world the wealthy area's almost always vote centre-right and by large margins even if they are socially liberal and in the big cities. Why does America buck this trend?
Simple answer, our cultural DNA.
Americans would rather live in danger as a wolf than live in complete safety as a sheep.
Americans would rather live freely in poverty than be wealthy as a slave.
Public discourse over the past century has been almost entirely centered on that line of thinking as well as justifying deviations from it. As an example, of course Americans want health care, and think everyone else should have health care. We just don't think it's the Federal governments responsibility to provide it, nor should we be mandated to purchase it.
When it comes to gun control, most of us would rather live in a dangerous society where we are free to defend ourselves, than live as slaves reliant on the government to protect our lives.
If you understand the cultural logic behind Americans, our entire political system will make sense.
I know the libertarian mindset is why America is the most supportive of small government and culturally conservative, but I don't see how that explains why your wealthiest areas vote for a centre-left party. Everywhere else the wealthy areas will vote staunchly right-wing because of economic issues, even if they are socially liberal. Similarly working class areas will vote staunchly left-wing even if they are socially conservative.
My guess is one of these two reasons...
#1) Wealthy elitist who get more wealthy with the Democrats in charge. As I have pointed out in this thread, the more power and control the Democrats have, the better the rich do and the worse everyone else does. More Democrats, means more regulations, means more govt., means less chance for the middle class to compete and become wealthy.
#2) A lot of easy living in the USA. The last true war in the USA was 150 years ago. So that is around about 7 generations of not having to face war or the consequences from it at home. Lots of wealthy people live in a bubble. They inherited their wealth. They don't know how the world works. They don't know how brutal life can be. They think if we just got together with the bad guys and sang kum-bi-ya that magically war would end overnight. They think if the rich pay more in taxes that magically poverty will end overnight. And that is as far as they want to think, then they go shopping, get drunk, party, then hate themselves for deep down knowing they are slugs and lash out then pass out.
(11-05-2014 07:36 AM)Deluge Wrote:(11-05-2014 06:53 AM)worldwidetraveler Wrote:(11-05-2014 02:02 AM)Cattle Rustler Wrote:(11-04-2014 07:48 PM)worldwidetraveler Wrote:(11-04-2014 07:23 PM)Brian Shima Wrote: Cattle Rustler someone earlier in the thread mention that you do oil work. Why would you vote for a Democrat and put your job on the line and not stay neutral? I mean Green Party seriously!? They would love to shut down oil rigs and leave thousands without work
I don't think CR works which is probably why he voted Democrat. hah
The more you know.....(and I do work)
First of all, I am neither a Republican nor Democrat.
With that said, let's talk about that chart, which is based on 2005 data. What exactly entails a state being a republican or a state being democrat according to your chart?
I'll give you a hint, some of those republican states would fit democrat states according to the same logic used for that chart...
The chart says based on who they voted for in the 2004 Presidential race. I'm curious as to how American's can explain that Red vs Blue federal budget gap.
There's also a big gap in income:
This is unique to America post the mid-20th century party realignment. In the rest of the Western world the wealthy area's almost always vote centre-right and by large margins even if they are socially liberal and in the big cities. Why does America buck this trend?
(11-05-2014 08:26 AM)Deluge Wrote:(11-05-2014 08:10 AM)It_is_my_time Wrote:(11-05-2014 07:57 AM)Deluge Wrote:(11-05-2014 07:50 AM)Blick Mang Wrote:(11-05-2014 07:36 AM)Deluge Wrote: This is unique to America post the mid-20th century party realignment. In the rest of the Western world the wealthy area's almost always vote centre-right and by large margins even if they are socially liberal and in the big cities. Why does America buck this trend?
Simple answer, our cultural DNA.
Americans would rather live in danger as a wolf than live in complete safety as a sheep.
Americans would rather live freely in poverty than be wealthy as a slave.
Public discourse over the past century has been almost entirely centered on that line of thinking as well as justifying deviations from it. As an example, of course Americans want health care, and think everyone else should have health care. We just don't think it's the Federal governments responsibility to provide it, nor should we be mandated to purchase it.
When it comes to gun control, most of us would rather live in a dangerous society where we are free to defend ourselves, than live as slaves reliant on the government to protect our lives.
If you understand the cultural logic behind Americans, our entire political system will make sense.
I know the libertarian mindset is why America is the most supportive of small government and culturally conservative, but I don't see how that explains why your wealthiest areas vote for a centre-left party. Everywhere else the wealthy areas will vote staunchly right-wing because of economic issues, even if they are socially liberal. Similarly working class areas will vote staunchly left-wing even if they are socially conservative.
My guess is one of these two reasons...
#1) Wealthy elitist who get more wealthy with the Democrats in charge. As I have pointed out in this thread, the more power and control the Democrats have, the better the rich do and the worse everyone else does. More Democrats, means more regulations, means more govt., means less chance for the middle class to compete and become wealthy.
#2) A lot of easy living in the USA. The last true war in the USA was 150 years ago. So that is around about 7 generations of not having to face war or the consequences from it at home. Lots of wealthy people live in a bubble. They inherited their wealth. They don't know how the world works. They don't know how brutal life can be. They think if we just got together with the bad guys and sang kum-bi-ya that magically war would end overnight. They think if the rich pay more in taxes that magically poverty will end overnight. And that is as far as they want to think, then they go shopping, get drunk, party, then hate themselves for deep down knowing they are slugs and lash out then pass out.
Neither of your guesses are adequate. Your second point is true of the other wealthy countries as well, and even more true of certain wealthy countries than America, i.e Australia which has never had a "real war" and hasn't had an economic downturn since the late 80's.
For your first point, I'm sure you'll agree most high income people want less taxes and less regulation on their businesses, which are both centre-right platforms and both small business owners and the big corporations vote for them and donate to those parties. There's definitely some very wealthy people who might benefit personally from left-wing legislation like Obamacare, but that doesn't explain this, they're still a tiny portion of the electorate and it can't be because of their political influence/donations because the elites in other countries can do exactly the same. Since we're talking about voters here, think of it from a local level. Why is your typical upper-middle class family in Westchester County, New York voting left? Why is a working class family in Kentuky voting right? In the U.K, Australia, Germany, France, Scandinavia etc. it would be the other way around.
(11-05-2014 07:36 AM)Deluge Wrote: The chart says based on who they voted for in the 2004 Presidential race. I'm curious as to how American's can explain that Red vs Blue federal budget gap.
Quote:There's also a big gap in income:
(11-05-2014 08:58 AM)DChambers Wrote: Are your center-right platforms any similar to the conservative policies in the U.S.?
(11-05-2014 08:13 AM)TravelerKai Wrote: Mitch McConnell said last night that one of the first things he wants to push through to Obama is a tax bill to lower taxable income on overseas income. Let's watch and see if they keep their word on that. God knows all us aspiring entrepreneurs that want to be financially and location independent really need this. It doesn't matter what your political affiliations are, the witch hunt on expats needs to stop.
(11-05-2014 09:30 AM)Deluge Wrote: @worldwidetraveller overall America's blue states have higher incomes and higher GDP per capita's then red states, and you can see this play out very clearly on the county level income map I posted.
Quote:Allen won the primary in June to take the state Senate seat left behind by Democrat Ted Lieu. According to LA Weekly, the Santa Monica-Malibu school board member held a 22-point lead over Fluke after more than half of the votes were in.
(11-05-2014 11:04 AM)elabayarde Wrote: Because repubs have a way of insulting every minority(which about half are men) at some point showing the utter disregarded for people of other creeds, races, ethnicities. Also Fox News paints repubs to be all extremely xenophobic. It's not true, but, conservatives don't disagree with the views enough to really put an end to the nonsense.
(11-05-2014 10:09 AM)worldwidetraveler Wrote:(11-05-2014 09:30 AM)Deluge Wrote: @worldwidetraveller overall America's blue states have higher incomes and higher GDP per capita's then red states, and you can see this play out very clearly on the county level income map I posted.
Higher incomes in places like California and New York is the same as lower income in the midwest if we are talking about disposable income.
You seem to be trying to push some sort of agenda.
![[Image: household-buying-power-maptitude-map.jpg]](http://www.caliper.com/featured-maps/household-buying-power-maptitude-map.jpg)