MOVSM
True Player
    
Posts: 1,594
Joined: Aug 2016
Reputation: 21
|
RE: Lifter's Lounge
I am afraid that women appreciate cruelty, downright cruelty, more than anything else. They have wonderfully primitive instincts. We have emancipated them, but they remain slaves looking for their masters all the same. They love being dominated.
--Oscar Wilde
|
|
| 04-20-2018 08:20 AM |
|
|
YoungBlade
True Player
    
Posts: 2,846
Joined: Sep 2015
Reputation: 54
|
|
| 04-20-2018 12:20 PM |
|
The following 1 user Likes YoungBlade's post:1 user Likes YoungBlade's post
kaotic
|
scorpion
True Player
    
Posts: 2,466
Joined: Sep 2012
Reputation: 253
|
RE: Lifter's Lounge
(04-21-2018 12:42 PM)Horus Wrote: I'm recovering from a shoulder injury and I've decided that I've officially retired from bench pressing for the rest of my life. In fact I don't think it's a good idea for me to do any pressing movements for a very long time - I can barely do 2 pushups without pain. At the moment the only chest exercises I can comfortably do are machine flies and cable flies. I'm happy to just keep doing that for a the time being, even though it's boring as fuck for me, but does any one have any recommendations for other chest exercises I can do to keep me interested?
If you're a recreational lifter (99% of the people reading this) please don't gloss over this post. What happened to Horus is all-too common. There is absolutely no reason for anyone except competitive powerlifters to bench press. None. It's a terrible exercise from every standpoint. I tried to warn guys about this awhile ago: /thread-38933...pid1376181
scorpion Wrote:Reminder that heavy benching is the absolute worst lift:
- Has killed and/or maimed hundreds of people over the years
- Seriously injured countless millions of shoulders
- Athletically and biomechanically useless as a power movement
- Inferior to numerous other exercises for pectoral hypertrophy
- Completely unnecessary for achieving imposing and aesthetic upper body development
Anyone who considers themselves a casual lifter has zero business bench pressing. If your goals in lifting are all about feeling and looking better (99% of people) then you shouldn't be benching. You do not need to bench to get big and strong. You do not need to bench to have a big chest. You do not need to bench to development athletic upper body power. The only thing you're likely to get from benching is fucked up shoulders a few years down the road that will not only limit your future ability to lift, but very likely require surgery, months of rehab and even then leave you with reduced strength and range of motion in your shoulders.
I've honestly lost count of how many guys I've met over the years who had nagging shoulder problems resulting from bench pressing. A staggering number. The shoulder, being the joint with the widest range of motion, is already at the greatest risk for injury. Overloading it with hundreds of pounds at a biomechanically awkward and anatomically unnatural angle is a recipe for disaster.
Stop benching. Just stop entirely. You will thank yourself ten, twenty or even fifty years from now when you are still able to enjoy the benefits of lifting while guys who tied their egos to the heavy bench can't even lift their arms over their heads.
STOP BENCH PRESSING
STOP BENCH PRESSING
STOP BENCH PRESSING
Pushups, dips, cable flies, dumbbell flies will give you all the chest development you need without compromising your shoulders. Combined with pullups, bent over rows, standing overhead press (a much better lift bio-mechanically for loading the shoulders) and shrugs you won't lack any accompanying upper body development.
"For I reckon that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed in us.” - Romans 8:18
|
|
| 04-21-2018 08:14 PM |
|
The following 4 users Like scorpion's post:4 users Like scorpion's post
Horus, sterling_archer, Intuitive, Grizzly Bear
|
scorpion
True Player
    
Posts: 2,466
Joined: Sep 2012
Reputation: 253
|
RE: Lifter's Lounge
(04-22-2018 09:43 AM)sterling_archer Wrote: Scorpion refers to "heavy benching" as dangerous. My question is, over what weight bench press can be referred as dangerously heavy? I am asking because SS, the program I will follow from tomorrow on for some time has bench pressing as one of its core exercises. I don't want to fall into the trap of changing the program by myself, which is a lot of newbies do and ultimately fail because of it.
I don't think there's really a hard and fast rule for as for what amount of weight you can safely do on a bench press in order to minimize damage to the shoulders. But I would say that the weight would be substantially less than a 1RM or even a 5RM like you'd be doing in SS. A 20RM would probably be more in the ballpark, done slowly with maximal recruitment of the pectorals the way Steelex describes. And really, at that point you might as well just be doing slow rep (3-5s up and down) pushups with your feet elevated off the floor, which accomplishes essentially the same muscular recruitment but is biomechanically much less taxing on the shoulder joint.
As for your fear of failing on the program, I would counter that a fear of sustaining a life-changing shoulder injury that great hampers your training capacity in the future would be more appropriate. There's no reason you can't make substantial gains with a modified SS that focuses on squats, deads, overhead presses and substitutes pushups and dips for bench. Remember that the pectorals themselves are functionally (and athletically) some of the least important muscles on the body. Look at the majority of professional athletes across every sport. You will find very little noticeable hypertrophy of the chest compared to the much more athletically important posterior chain. Massives pecs are really a bodybuilding thing. It's pure aesthetics. And you do not need to bench to induce hypertrophy in the pecs. There are superior exercises for that and they are easier on the shoulders than benching.
What I'm basically saying is that by cutting out bench you really aren't sacrificing anything. You aren't leaving gains on the table. You can make the same gains with other exercises, and you can do so with substantially less wear and tear on your shoulders. Some people reject this stance as overly conservative, but I think that weight training should be undertaken with the Hippocratic principle of "first, do no harm". You're lifting weights to look better and feel better. The weight is a tool, not an end in and of itself. The amount of weight you're lifting and how you lift it doesn't really matter. The end goal is self-improvement, which means you want to end up better than you started. That makes injury prevention paramount. This should be treated as a marathon, not a sprint. God willing, I will be healthy enough to lift up through my 80s. That's why joint health is a priority for me, and should be for all lifters who want to stay in the game for decades to come.
"For I reckon that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed in us.” - Romans 8:18
|
|
| 04-22-2018 11:01 AM |
|
The following 3 users Like scorpion's post:3 users Like scorpion's post
sterling_archer, ElFlaco, Jack Gignac
|
Fortis
International Playboy
     
Posts: 4,255
Joined: May 2014
Reputation: 104
|
RE: Lifter's Lounge
(04-21-2018 11:50 PM)Steelex Wrote: Man...
The bench gets a bad rap because it's executed poorly.
Everyone arches the shit out of their back and bounces it up, which doesn't do much for the chest and puts a ton of pressure on the shoulder.
I avoid many of the pitfalls of the bench by stopping a few inches off the chest and using a slow 4 count negative on the way down, which forces me to use a lower weight than if I did fast reps. I focus on keeping the pec involved.
It's a tool for chest development, but if you do it the way everyone else does its more dangerous than effective.
I thought you were supposed to arch your back, or is that only a thing because powerlifters are trying to shorten the bar path?
I've never had any shoulder problems from benching, dipping and overhead pressing multiple times a week for months on end. However, I keep the weight reasonable.
I tend to find that most dudes fuck themselves up on bench because of ego. I "look" like I can go a lot heavier than I do in the gym, but I find to find that my development doesn't slow down when I drop the weight down a few pegs and go for multiple sets at medium reps. Some would probably look at me and say "You could go a lot heavier than that!" but I don't really worry too much about it at this stage. I'm almost thirty, so I always try to look after my joints.
Whenever I feel like something is off, I cycle exercises out for a few weeks to let my body recover and then come back to it.
At the end of the day, we can blame exercises, but it's often our ego that gets us into trouble.
I will be checking my PMs weekly, so you can catch me there. I will not be posting.
(This post was last modified: 04-22-2018 06:59 PM by Fortis.)
|
|
| 04-22-2018 06:57 PM |
|
|
Intuitive
Game Denialist
Posts: 64
Joined: Mar 2014
Reputation: 0
|
RE: Lifter's Lounge
(04-21-2018 08:14 PM)scorpion Wrote: If you're a recreational lifter (99% of the people reading this) please don't gloss over this post. What happened to Horus is all-too common. There is absolutely no reason for anyone except competitive powerlifters to bench press. None. It's a terrible exercise from every standpoint. I tried to warn guys about this awhile ago: /thread-38933...pid1376181
scorpion Wrote:Reminder that heavy benching is the absolute worst lift:
- Has killed and/or maimed hundreds of people over the years
- Seriously injured countless millions of shoulders
- Athletically and biomechanically useless as a power movement
- Inferior to numerous other exercises for pectoral hypertrophy
- Completely unnecessary for achieving imposing and aesthetic upper body development
Anyone who considers themselves a casual lifter has zero business bench pressing. If your goals in lifting are all about feeling and looking better (99% of people) then you shouldn't be benching. You do not need to bench to get big and strong. You do not need to bench to have a big chest. You do not need to bench to development athletic upper body power. The only thing you're likely to get from benching is fucked up shoulders a few years down the road that will not only limit your future ability to lift, but very likely require surgery, months of rehab and even then leave you with reduced strength and range of motion in your shoulders.
I've honestly lost count of how many guys I've met over the years who had nagging shoulder problems resulting from bench pressing. A staggering number. The shoulder, being the joint with the widest range of motion, is already at the greatest risk for injury. Overloading it with hundreds of pounds at a biomechanically awkward and anatomically unnatural angle is a recipe for disaster.
Stop benching. Just stop entirely. You will thank yourself ten, twenty or even fifty years from now when you are still able to enjoy the benefits of lifting while guys who tied their egos to the heavy bench can't even lift their arms over their heads.
STOP BENCH PRESSING
STOP BENCH PRESSING
STOP BENCH PRESSING
Pushups, dips, cable flies, dumbbell flies will give you all the chest development you need without compromising your shoulders. Combined with pullups, bent over rows, standing overhead press (a much better lift bio-mechanically for loading the shoulders) and shrugs you won't lack any accompanying upper body development.
I tend to agree as the only chest barbell movement that has never caused me any problems is the incline press. I am currently doing decline press and I've felt a light twinge in my shoulder as I've moved into the 6-8 rep range.
Playing devil's advocate here-- with regards to your suggested isolation/bodyweight movements as substitutes, would that logic apply to all other bodyparts from a hypertrophy perspective? For example, lunges and leg extensions instead of squats? I just don't see the necessary muscle recruitment occurring without some heavier compound moves.
|
|
| 04-23-2018 09:31 AM |
|
|