Post: #1

I run into this a lot and can't figure out a smooth transition - or maybe it just feels awkward to me because i havent wrapped my head around its acceptability yet.

talking to a 2set composed of a hottie & fattie. conversation is going good and I get IOIs from both the fattie and the hottie. For the life of me I cannot figure out how to smoothly show the fattie I'm not interested in her, but rather I'm interested in the hottie without the fattie getting upset and cockblocking and ending the set.

What I've done in the past is keep the convo going for 5-10 minute and then let it sort of wind down naturally. Then as we're getting ready to say goodbye I directly tell the hottie, "we should hang out some time, here whats your number." But so far out of the last 5-6 times I've done this I haven't number-closed, which is a combination of factors that I attribute mostly to me screwing up my game with hottie/fattie situations.

Do you guys have any direct IOI lines or role play sequence in hottie/fattie situations?

Post: #2

Has anyone tried a good cop/bad cop game in such a case? I mean being nice to the fat chick and being an ass to the hottie.

Post: #3

I don't think it has anything to do with hottie and fattie situation. Did you have better result with 2 hotties?

you said you talked to them 5~10 minutes. If they are saying 'we have friends coming', 'we are going to check out upstairs' 'we are going to grab a drink', they are just rejecting you.
You can still ask her number but I am sure it would be a flake.

Just be nice to both of them. If you are in a good shape, the fattie exactly knows she doesn't have a chance with you. Just don't make it obvious.